A Night of High Notes and Heartbreak: American Idol Shocks Fans with Top 7 Results
As Season 23 of American Idol nears its dramatic conclusion, Sunday night’s Top 7 episode delivered not just powerful performances—but shocking eliminations that left fans reeling.
After a night dedicated to Disney classics and moving Mother’s Day tributes, two standout contestants were unexpectedly sent home: Gabby Samone, the last remaining Black female singer, and Mattie Pruitt, the competition’s youngest performer at just 16 years old.
Despite a record-breaking 20 million votes—up 5 million from the previous week—viewers were stunned by the outcome. Within minutes of host Ryan Seacrest announcing the Top 5, social media was ablaze with disbelief and outrage.
Gabby Samone’s Standout Performances Fall Short in Votes
Gabby took on “How Far I’ll Go” from Moana, coached by the song’s creator, Lin-Manuel Miranda. He admitted the song’s complexity, but Gabby’s vocal strength and determination paid off. Lionel Richie called her performance “spoiling,” while Carrie Underwood told her, “Your voice was made for songs like that.”
For her second performance, Gabby sang “Home” from The Wiz—a touching dedication to her mother, Charoletta. It was a raw, emotional moment that moved the judges and audience alike. Carrie Underwood called her talent “ridiculous.”
But even with two powerhouse performances, Gabby’s name was not called for the Top 5.
Fan Outrage Explodes Online: “Gabby Was ROBBED”
The reaction from fans was immediate and intense. Twitter (X) lit up with outrage, many questioning the integrity of the voting system, citing racial bias, and expressing disbelief.
“Gabby, Breanna, Jamal, Canaan, Ché – that’s the REAL Top 5.” – @retrowater0
“Gabby going home tonight is a crime against women.” – @skittyspiece
“She was the best vocalist in decades. Shameful.” – @Illianonyc
“Gabby voted out? Yeah, this show isn’t fixed. And I have a bridge for sale.” – @Carol_E_Zanetti
While some vented frustration, others offered support and encouragement:
“Tonight didn’t go your way, but you’re going places. Keep chasing your dreams.” – @Stephan61047444
A Tough Goodbye to Mattie Pruitt
Also sent home was Mattie Pruitt, the youngest contestant left in the competition. Her exit, though less controversial, was still emotional for fans who admired her growth and youthful charm throughout the season.
What’s Next — and What’s at Stake
With the Top 5 moving forward, Gabby’s sudden exit has left a noticeable void. The controversy has reignited debates over American Idol’s voting system, with many calling for greater transparency or change.
As the finale approaches, producers may feel mounting pressure to address growing concerns over fairness, representation, and whether the show truly rewards talent—or just popularity.
Why This Moment Matters for Idol’s Future
Season 23 has been praised for its talent pool, but Sunday night may mark a turning point. The eliminations of Gabby Samone and Mattie Pruitt weren’t just unexpected—they’ve become a flashpoint in a conversation about who gets heard, and why.
And that’s why this season might go down as one of the most emotional—and most debated—in American Idol history.