Carrie Underwood recently appeared in a video for American Idol, showcasing her outfit for an episode. However, instead of focusing on her style, many online users speculated that she had altered her appearance.
Over the weekend, American Idol shared a clip on Instagram featuring Underwood as she twirled to give viewers a full look at her ensemble. Dressed in a blue denim jacket with a zippered back and a large matching bow at the neck, she paired it with a ruffled black-and-white distressed denim skirt adorned with gold buttons. Completing the look, she wore stylish blue denim heels.
As the video ended, Underwood playfully flicked her blonde ponytail, with the post captioned, “Bow yes she did. 🩵✨ #IDOL #fitcheck.” However, the comment section quickly shifted from her fashion choices to her face. Some questioned changes in her appearance, particularly her lips, with remarks like, “What did she do to her lips?” and “She looks so different, too much filler in her face and lips.”
Others expressed concern over what they perceived as excessive cosmetic work, while a few defended her, praising her beauty and fit physique. Despite the criticism, Underwood confidently embraced her bold look.
Meanwhile, American Idol entered a new era this season, sparking debate among fans. The show premiered on March 9, 2025, bringing back host Ryan Seacrest alongside judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie. However, the biggest change was the addition of Underwood, replacing Katy Perry on the panel.
Reactions to her new role were mixed. Some viewers were excited to see a former Idol winner guiding contestants, while others missed Perry’s more animated and playful approach. Critics called Underwood “too serious,” with some even labeling her “boring.” Others, however, saw her as a great addition, believing her experience as a past contestant would provide valuable insight.
Just before her American Idol debut, Underwood made headlines with a striking appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon on March 5, 2025. Wearing a sleek metallic mini dress that highlighted her toned legs, she captivated fans. However, once again, some focused more on her facial features than her fashion, questioning whether she had undergone cosmetic enhancements.
Underwood later joined Bryan and Richie for a fun segment on Fallon Tonight, where she shared her excitement about joining American Idol. While she admitted feeling nervous about critiquing contestants, she emphasized her desire to support aspiring artists.
Her return to American Idol as a judge marks a full-circle moment, nearly two decades after winning the competition in 2005. In a recent interview, she reflected on that life-changing experience, recalling how surreal it felt to go from a small-town girl to a global star.
Beyond television, Underwood also made waves when she performed America the Beautiful at Donald Trump’s inauguration as the 47th U.S. president on January 20, 2025. Wearing a sophisticated dove-gray midi dress, she took the stage alongside the Armed Forces Chorus.
A technical glitch left her without instrumental backing, prompting her to ask the crowd to sing along. While some praised her for handling the situation gracefully, others critiqued her vocals, noting that she sounded “off-key.” Despite the mixed reactions, Underwood remained unfazed, expressing gratitude for the opportunity to perform at such a significant event.
Her decision to participate in the inauguration was met with controversy, but a source close to her clarified that it was not a political endorsement. Instead, it was a tribute to the country that had supported her throughout her career.
From her fashion choices to her role on American Idol and high-profile performances, Carrie Underwood continues to spark conversation. Whether praised or critiqued, she remains a prominent figure in entertainment, embracing both new opportunities and the challenges that come with them.